sillie1111 0 #1 May 11, 2004 Ok before I start I will let you know I have spoken with my instructors and have taken in their advice. I still would like to know how others feel about this. I am about to get my A I have one jump left I started AFF in Sept. I have 24 jumps and my canopy control is good from what I have been told, I do also agree that my control is good, and I am very comfortable with it.I feel I am ready to get my own gear. I have one problem with the student rigs, I jump a Raider 220 and I am to small for it, i think the term is underloading?. I attempted to do front riser turns and hung from them, they wouldn't go anywhere. when the winds are at 10 miles and hour I don't go anywhere but down, no forward penetration! Pretty boring canopy ride. I have been looking at a sabre 170, I have been told that for my size a 170 will be ok for me at 125 lbs. The reserve of course is a 175. I would like to know what people feel about that. At my dropzone I have people who agree that a 170 is ok for a first rig, but then I have a few who say I should not jump from a 220 to a 170. I would appreciate it if I could get some more feedback from different people. I would like to demo a different rig before I buy one, but the problem is I cant find one with my container size they are all to big. Even the student rig is to big and hurts my legs. Thanks~Shelly Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
piisfish 140 #2 May 11, 2004 if your instructors say it would be ok for you to jump a 170, then go for it, but if possible jump a few times some intermediate size, do it gradually. listen to what your instructors say.scissors beat paper, paper beat rock, rock beat wingsuit - KarlM Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
betzilla 56 #3 May 11, 2004 My first canopy was a Sabre 170, and I weighed about 160 at the time. I bought that one at 50-ish jumps, and before that had jumped a Manta (25 jumps), a Raider (1 jump), a Triathlon 220 (10-15 jumps), Triathlon 190 (5 jumps), and a Triathlon 175 (5-10 jumps). After all that, the Sabre 170 was no big whoop for me. It was really fun and easy to fly. You'll be at a pretty conservative wingloading, and your instructors think you're ready, so go for it! Try to get a few jumps on something in between the two sizes first, and if you're nervous, have someone put you on a radio for your first couple jumps on it. Respect the new canopy, and it'll treat you fine. -B Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sillie1111 0 #4 May 11, 2004 "and if you're nervous, have someone put you on a radio for your first couple jumps on it. " When I was in AFF I lost radio twice both times at the beginning of my landing pattern.I did very well without it so, with the instructors ok of course I stopped using radio before I got on solo status. I must say I am a bit nervous to jump a new rig, a big part of that is because I had my first hard pull 3 weeks ago and it scared the hell out of me , I ended up opening lower then I wanted to . I have had 24 jumps on the Raider, and I know that doesn't seem like a lot but I can tell when I am having a normal good opening. I know if I was on a different canopy and I wasn't sure how the openings are, it can be faster, harder ect. I probly would have freeked out. But when my big old 220 Raider came out of the bag I felt relief like no other! I cant wait to get more experience with a bit more performance but I defiantly don't want to put to much on my plate. Thanks for the feed back ~Michelle~Shelly Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bch7773 0 #5 May 12, 2004 if you have been jumping a 220 and your instructors say you are ready for a 170, don't forget you can either borrow someone's 190 and jump in a few times, or you can demo a 190 from a gear store, or demo a sabre 190 from PD. and btw, it doesn't have to be a 190, you could choose any size between 220 and 170... 190 is just a common size in there. having a few jumps on a slightly smaller canopy will give you confidence, or if your landings don't go well on the 190, consider getting a 190 instead of the 170, or sticking with the 220 a little longer. MB 3528, RB 1182 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nael 0 #6 May 12, 2004 I have another question along the same lines as this. Although I'm not getting a rig of my own for a few more jumps I've been looking into it and talking to lots of people at the dz. I have a similar problem in that I am pretty small under the student 220 canopies. I would have a wingloading of 1:1 on a 150, which I am not comfortable with (and have had many discussions with experienced jumpers trying to get me to buy a 150 for my first canopy), so would be looking at a 170 also. Now, the question - I have yet to stand up a landing but I've heard the student canopies can be more difficult to have a good landing on than a smaller canopy, is this true or are people just trying to make me feel better?www.TerminalSports.com.auAustralia's largest skydive gear store Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vt1977 0 #7 May 12, 2004 At around 50 jumps (I was a slow learner on static line progression ) I went from a Raider 220 which was my student canopy straight to a PD-170 which I had bought. I weighed about the same as you too. I stood up the first landing on the 170 in the peas… . It was a very big step down and if I were to do it again, I would definitely try to put a few jumps on a 190 in between. Having said that though, the 170 was a great canopy for me to learn on and I kept it for the best part of 400 jumps.Speak to your instructors and get their views, but it would certainly not do you any harm to put a few jumps on a 190 if you possibly can. As for the reserve, if you and your instructors feel comfortable with you jumping a 170 main, then IMHO there is nothing at all wrong with having a 175 reserve. Usual stuff - make sure you have a rigger check over any kit you are thinking of buying before parting with any cash. Good luck! Vicki Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dmbale 0 #8 May 12, 2004 If at all possible, do not skip a size. I went from a 218 to a 190 at around 50 jumps and felt like an AFF student again. Even if you only do 5-10 jumps on each size inbetween, you will thank yourself. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites