Recommended Posts
TheAnvil 0
Enter TheAnvil into the thread. Nice piece of work. I've been busy this week, so I had to speed read this. Quite fascinating comments from many.
Did he say we are engaged in a jihad? Hmm. I didn't hear that. If so, how can stating that we are engaged in a holy war with those who have declared a holy war on us increase casualties in any way? I doubt that it can. The latest FCUK ad, though British, will arouse much more furor than rhetoric from a previously little known military officer.
A general should know better - 'tis true - when speaking in his official capacity or inferred official capacity when wearing his/her uniform. However, this analogy is so far removed from what he actually said that I can't really see its place here.
Quote
I have no problem with anyone expressing their views on religion. I do have a problem with one of our military leaders saying the US is engaged in a jihad. That will, in the end, get more of our soldiers killed - and that's bad whether or not you're in the military.
Did he say we are engaged in a jihad? Hmm. I didn't hear that. If so, how can stating that we are engaged in a holy war with those who have declared a holy war on us increase casualties in any way? I doubt that it can. The latest FCUK ad, though British, will arouse much more furor than rhetoric from a previously little known military officer.
Quote
Imagine, for example, a US army general giving a speech on the eve of a nuclear disarmament talk with China who says "The US will crush China as soon as China becomes weak." That may be covered by free speech, but I would also think that general is an idiot for saying something that might just scuttle those disarmament talks. A general should know better.
A general should know better - 'tis true - when speaking in his official capacity or inferred official capacity when wearing his/her uniform. However, this analogy is so far removed from what he actually said that I can't really see its place here.
Vinny the Anvil
Post Traumatic Didn't Make The Lakers Syndrome is REAL
JACKASS POWER!!!!!!
Post Traumatic Didn't Make The Lakers Syndrome is REAL
JACKASS POWER!!!!!!
>criticizing someone for stating their religious views, in a country where
>free speech is protected, and ignoring comments like these:
I think that comment is foolish as well.
I have no problem with anyone expressing their views on religion. I do have a problem with one of our military leaders saying the US is engaged in a jihad. That will, in the end, get more of our soldiers killed - and that's bad whether or not you're in the military.
Imagine, for example, a US army general giving a speech on the eve of a nuclear disarmament talk with China who says "The US will crush China as soon as China becomes weak." That may be covered by free speech, but I would also think that general is an idiot for saying something that might just scuttle those disarmament talks. A general should know better.
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites