TheMarshMan1 0 #1 January 22, 2002 AWESOME MOVIE!!!Just thought I'd give it my personal recommendation to you all....-Marshall Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skybytch 273 #2 January 22, 2002 I'm reading the book right now... not sure I want to see the movie, the book is incredibly graphic.pull and flare,lisa-- Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skymama 37 #3 January 22, 2002 I haven't seen the movie yet, but the real life Danny McKnight is an old friend of the family. AndreaThe brave may not live forever, but the timid may not live at all. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PhreeZone 20 #4 January 22, 2002 The movie left me speechless along withthe rest of the crowd last night. High intensive explosions, grapfic as anything I've ever seen (Movies or real life), and it showed just how willing some people are willing to go to proctect others.I can't reccommend the movie enough. Everyone should leave with a new respect for a lot of things at the end of it.I want to touch the sky, I want to fly so high ~ Sonique Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Stacy 0 #5 January 22, 2002 the movie was so well made.. it seemed almost like real time. i'm gonna steal jimbo's word- intense. edge of the seat the entire time and yes it was graphic. they didn't skimp on anything. but painted a clear picture. haven't seen one like that since Glory.Stacyhttp://users.snip.net/~stacy Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Shark 0 #6 January 22, 2002 Quote I'm reading the book right now... not sure I want to see the movie, the book is incredibly graphic.It is, and I believe the "visuals" will reinforce the book.M Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ojf1982 0 #7 January 22, 2002 The movie really left me speechless at the end. I knew about what happened but i didnt know to the extent that the movie showed. And yes it is a very very graphic movie.Omar B-24801 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SniperCJ 0 #8 January 22, 2002 I agree. Great movie. Read the book about a year ago and the movie did the book justice. Very intense. The part where everyone is making preparations for the operation and 'getting their minds right' mirrors what I see and do before a particularly intense SWAT operation. (certainly not to say Ive ever experienced ANYTHING that intense).Go see it!JC Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Jimbo 0 #9 January 22, 2002 Yup. It was intense. It was graphic, though not excessively. It was an excellent movie. -Jim Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skybytch 273 #10 January 22, 2002 Quote the real life Danny McKnight is an old friend of the familyHe's probably heard this before and probably will get more now that the movie's out.. but after reading that book and learning about what those guys went through, please if you talk to him tell him someone he doesn't even know says thank you.pull and flare,lisa-- Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Jesse 0 #11 January 22, 2002 Andrea,I would be interested in what COL McKnight is doing now. I arrived at 3rd Ranger Battalion (the unit depicted in the movie) about 12 months after the events in Mogadishu and COL McKnight had already changed command. I know General Garrison sort of took the fall for the results of the mission - testifying before Congress, etc., he was not promoted. I heard that COL McKnight was promoted to O-6 (full Colonel) but was not selected for Brigade Command and was sent by the Army to serve as the Inspector General for the Virginia State National Guard. Do you know if that's true or if he is still living in Virginia, retired, or still on active duty? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skymedic 0 #12 January 22, 2002 I would recomend it...but the book to me was much more graphic(maybe I have an intense imagination)....what was tough though...was that the 3 rows in front of me in the theatre had VIP seating of the rangers that starred in the fast rope parts of the movie..and also had about 10 of the rangers that were actualy in the convoy...at the end where they listed the dead, one guy stood up and said he was about one bullet away from that list....it is very humbling to see these towering soldiers walk out and cry.......amazing movie...and humbling....marc"...a mind stretched with new idea's will never regain its shape" Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
3fLiEr 0 #13 January 22, 2002 I have heard that the movie is rather racist............ a modern day Zulu that portrays the Non-US as spear chucking savages with no personalisation of idividuals............... but hey thats American films for you........bias......... what was the film last year where the Americans re-wrote some of the history of WWII???........ ;opbsbd"In a world where we are slaves to gravity I am pleased to be a freedom fighter" Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skreamer 1 #14 January 22, 2002 Actually, at the end of the movie why did they only show the americans names who died? Over 1000 Somalis were killed (fighting in their OWN country). Were they all evil war-lords the way Hollywood would have us believe? How convenient....WillPS how come nobody thought of intervening when the genocide in Rwanda kicked off? No oil there I suppose.... Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
3fLiEr 0 #15 January 22, 2002 Well said Will!........................ bsbd"In a world where we are slaves to gravity I am pleased to be a freedom fighter" Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RemiAndKaren 0 #16 January 22, 2002 Quote PS how come nobody thought of intervening when the genocide in Rwanda kicked off? No oil there I suppose....OH OH I've got one too!How about when the Taliban took over YEARS ago and denied the most basic human rights to a good section of the citizen of Afganistan?OH OH I've got another one again!I come no ones still doesnt care about whats happening in Algeria where women, journalists, doctors, teachers are butchered?RemiMuff 914 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skreamer 1 #17 January 22, 2002 Gee, Remi, you are so stupid, the reason why nobody cares, is because teachers getting butchered in Algeria doesn't increase the price of gas in a 3-litre American corvette by 5c/gallon. Its those silly Algerians own fault for being persecuted in a country that is of no use to America.... Remi, you obviously know nothing about world politics and history - I'd suggest you spend more time at your local cinema (don't waste your time with newspapers and books). Will Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jfields 0 #18 January 22, 2002 Quote Remi, you obviously know nothing about world politics and history - I'd suggest you spend more time at your local cinema (don't waste your time with newspapers and books).Good point. You can also see plenty of movies outlining the imperial inhumanities of the British and the occasional film about white South African subjugation of the locals. What do I know. We were just a colony. Justin Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Nick 0 #19 January 22, 2002 3fLiErNot trying to kick anything up here but that movies was U-571, I know a lot of people over in the UK boycotted it.The reason being that the film gives credit to the Americans for recovering a German Enigma machine for decoding orders sent to their submarines. This was something that the British had actually accomplished and should be given credit for. The United States did not recover an Enigma machine till near the end of the war. Nick Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jfields 0 #20 January 22, 2002 Nick,You're right. One of the key participants was Alan Turing. After all his work, the British government ostracized him for being gay. Talk about gratitude for brilliant work in mathematics.... Justin Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
3fLiEr 0 #21 January 22, 2002 "You can also see plenty of movies outlining the imperial inhumanities of the British and the occasional film about white South African subjugation of the locals."made in such a way to show the acts in their true light................. not to show how the perpetrators are heroic…………………. ;opbsbd"In a world where we are slaves to gravity I am pleased to be a freedom fighter" Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jfields 0 #22 January 22, 2002 3fLieEr,Yes, you're right. Those movies don't glamourize the behaviors. And they were made in the same place as the moronic movies for the masses. Hollywood isn't all bad, just mostly bad. Justin Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
3fLiEr 0 #23 January 22, 2002 Hollywood isn't all bad, just mostly badNot enough tits in the movies!!! .......................;opbsbd"In a world where we are slaves to gravity I am pleased to be a freedom fighter" Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jfields 0 #24 January 22, 2002 Quote Not enough tits in the movies!!! ......That isn't precisely Hollywood. You just need to go to the other video stores. Justin Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Emma 0 #25 January 22, 2002 Not enough tits?I am yet to find a movie that shows enough PENISES for my liking...Oh yeh...but plenty of *dicks*, I guess you could say....Anyway..what was wrong with 'Zulu'? Bloody marvellous if you ask me, we showed those darkies a thing or two, what? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
