Recommended Posts
Continue please.
How do address today's complex political situation with your daily life?
"No bragging and no complaining".
I think the thought put forward was, do you reconize the current past as having any relevence to todays currency, (tommorrow's past).
skydyvr 0
QuoteContinue please.
Honestly, I don't converse much with complete strangers who say to me "I sense that you may be a lemming following the crowd without any individual thoughts". There's nothing I can say to that.
. . =(_8^(1)
QuoteYou have no idea who I am
Not once did I claim to know you
Don't you tell me who I kneel down and worship.
Quote
I never once said whom it is you kneel to and worship. Read it again as I only asked if you rather close your eyes to what is wrong. Your reply was extremely defensive and on one level a personal attack.
***...the very extreme ends of any political party -- that area is reserved for morons.
This statement implies that the founding fathers were morons as they were considered to be extreme.
Maybe, I am a throwback from the sixties and seventies as I still believe that this country can and should strive for less government and more personal freedom. You're free to call me and others morons, but why so defensive when I did not attack you?
When you're out of the blue and into the black."
Neil Young
skydyvr 0
QuoteRead it again as I only asked if you rather close your eyes to what is wrong. Your reply was extremely defensive and on one level a personal attack.
I saw no question marks in your question, but anyway . . .
Nothing personal, but I do believe political extremists are generally lesser thinkers than their moderate counterparts. The smartest people I know have a mixed, balanced set of belief systems.
. . =(_8^(1)
Lindsey 0
You can find all that is right and try to strengthen it.
I think at any given time we have some of both. Because someone isn't fighting against what is wrong doesn't mean they're doing nothing.
Peace~
linz
A conservative is just a liberal who's been mugged. A liberal is just a conservative who's been to jail
QuoteQuoteRead iit and ask yourself if this is true about America.
I believe it is.
The song describes the US in as negative a light as possible, but sure as hell doesn't reflect today's complete picture by any means.
It also fails to note that many of the things that it condemns the U.S. for doing are done in many other countries, and sometimes to far worse degree.
For example, is the U.S. the only country in the world to have slavery? Nope. And ours was abolished 150 or so years ago. There are countries that have it going on NOW.
Amazing that GENOCIDE is still going on in countries around the world -- countries are still ruled, in poverty, by ACTUAL DICTATORS -- and people berate the U.S., and call Bush a "dictator." Way to cheapen the word's meaning.
-
"With tha thoughts of a militant mind... Hard line, hard line after hard line!"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Be nice if the civilians could have a few when it's time to overthrow the U.S Govt.
I feel it, when I sorrow most;
'Tis better to have loved and lost
Than never to have loved at all.
pajarito 0
QuoteI am not a whinner! I am an antagonist!
I expected more from you, son. Think.
Son?....
jakee 1,489
QuoteIt also fails to note that many of the things that it condemns the U.S. for doing are done in many other countries, and sometimes to far worse degree.
So?
If you had secret police investigating you would it be OK as long as they're not as bad as the ones in China?
I'm not going to make any judgement against the US but that argument 'it's ok if we're unjust because because other countries are worse which makes us good' is just odd.
rehmwa 2
QuoteNothing personal, but I do believe political extremists are generally lesser thinkers than their moderate counterparts. The smartest people I know have a mixed, balanced set of belief systems.
This is really nicely stated. Extremists (in our country) do tend to not really think, only react to their 'guts'.
Every song with a political bent I've heard was just a bunch of clap designed to ellicit an emotional response, not really think. Shallow script from one extreme or the other. Certainly that's what music is designed to do - ellicit an emotional response - so if we recognize that, then the song can be enjoyed without putting too much into it.
Political songs are no better than politicians giving speeches, only with crappy writing, some rhyming, and incessant repetition of nonsense. So again, it's good to enjoy it for the response it brings, but to take it seriously is nonsense - positions should be based on strong thinking and assessment, not emotive response.
...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants
QuoteYou can find all that is wrong and fight to get rid of it.
You can find all that is right and try to strengthen it.
I think at any given time we have some of both. Because someone isn't fighting against what is wrong doesn't mean they're doing nothing.
Peace~
linz
Linz, pretty much hit the nail on the head. My view is that this is what the song is about. Throughout our history there has been an enormous amount of injustice and the people recognized it and remedied the problem to make the US a greater nation that the world can see that all is not lost. The people have the right to rebel against the government if the government lose sight and waver from the path. I admire those who stand up and tell the powers that be where to shove it. That takes determination and a lot of guts as by doing so you open yourself up to investigation and to the critics. This happened to those who went against Joseph McCarthy. They were labeled as "commies" and many lost everything. Imagine how today would be if McCarthy was not exposed as a tyrannical nut. There is so much talk about spying on the people and that it is needed to find the bad guys. Well, in order to find the bad, you have to go down the entire list. Maybe that white middle class family down the street with 2.2 kids and a dog in the yard are part of a terrorist network. How will you ever know unless you look at everyone. What is the cost in order to expose them? The cost is being scrutinized yourself. So, you are not a terrorist, you have nothing to worry about if the government picks your life apart in order to learn you are not. Would you want to be under the light for them to be able to move on to the next person and pick them apart? I wouldn't and I don't. I have skeletons in my closet, just like you and you and you. We all do. I do not want the government going through my closet. I do not want them in my house, period. I do not want a return to the McCarthy era. I am not willing to give up my privacy in the name of "national security". Are you?
When you're out of the blue and into the black."
Neil Young
When you're out of the blue and into the black."
Neil Young
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites