0
Bolas

Possibly a argument for religion you may not have heard before...

Recommended Posts

Quote

>undeniable proof, with immediate consequences total change.

Yes, I agree there. If God struck you dead as soon as you picked up a gun to go after someone, then things would change fast. But that's prevention, not deterrence.



How about immediately after one pulled the trigger? If God really wanted to deter, could even stop the bullet from killing the other person.
Stupidity if left untreated is self-correcting
If ya can't be good, look good, if that fails, make 'em laugh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>How about immediately after one pulled the trigger? If God really wanted to
>deter, could even stop the bullet from killing the other person.

Or just ensure that any weapon fired at another person discharges backwards. Would solve the problem quite rapidly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

I can see, hear, smell, taste, and touch, therefore I am part of a self aware universe.



What??? Not sure what that means in the context of this thread.....



I was just providing a logical view to contrast with the two views you said were crap.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Quote

This is an age of technology where video and audio proof could substantiate anyone's claims.



Indeed! I saw video proof of Luke Skywalker destroying the Death Star.



OK. What would a god have to do to prove to you that they in fact exist? What physical/scientific proof would you need?



Well, someone talking directly to me out of a burning bush, when I was not sick or drunk, would be reasonably convincing.
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

A detriment to who or what? Human kind or those that say they God speaks to them?



There is a difference between a faith that satisfies and a faith that more than satisfies. Maadmax was just expressing a deep humble gratefulness by saying that God has already more than "proved" himself to him. The detriment, as I understood it, is to his heart.

Its like someone giving their life for you, and then you asking for proof that it was real. Or someone takes loving care of you your entire life and then, when they die, you ask for "proof" that they actually loved you at all. Someone can express love to someone else in great measures their entire life, but if that love is not believed or accepted, then it cant be recieved with the full measure it was given. I think you understand.
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I mean, imagine God coming to earth and saying "Every single major religion has got it wrong. You - Catholics - that Pope is ridiculous. I never meant anything like that to happen. And you really think 'don't eat pork' is important? And don't even get me started on minarets." You really think the Catholic Church would just give up all its power without a fight? That Muslims would stop praying five times a day? That Jews would start eating bacon? That the Palestinians would stop being so pissed off at the Jews? I could see a Pope conferring with a head of state somewhere, asking if the False God might be vulnerable to a nuclear strike before it's too late.



there is something very truthful about this statement. It also amplifies a "theory" (truth to me) that we are spiritual beings with very deep needs and wants in that "realm" (or some may submit to the word dimension). There is a voice of trust, of love, of hope, of confidence, of power, of light, of freedom ect... in this world of suffering, pain, confusion, worry, doubt, barriers, loss ect... We can get lost in one only to be found in the other. Depending on the voice, which seems to be a point in your statement, it seems we can either be led or misled, and i would have to agree that many are being misled... and if you dig into your soul, you may or may not agree.

It seems a spiritual truth is that we must be lost before we can be found... and yes, that is also in the Gospel. "So that the blind can see, and so that those who see will become blind"
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

>I'll admit that some of the more extremists groups might take the news
> badly if they were "wrong" and there may be mass suicides/homicides for
> a bit . . .

One of the reasons there isn't more religious violence right now is that most people don't really care that much. If you gave them a real, concrete reason to care, things would get uglier IMO.

I mean, imagine God coming to earth and saying "Every single major religion has got it wrong. You - Catholics - that Pope is ridiculous. I never meant anything like that to happen. And you really think 'don't eat pork' is important? And don't even get me started on minarets." You really think the Catholic Church would just give up all its power without a fight? That Muslims would stop praying five times a day? That Jews would start eating bacon? That the Palestinians would stop being so pissed off at the Jews? I could see a Pope conferring with a head of state somewhere, asking if the False God might be vulnerable to a nuclear strike before it's too late.

Believing in a religion can make people very fervent, sometimes violent. Having that belief destroyed can make them a lot more violent.



George Burns said it first.
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Well, someone talking directly to me out of a burning bush, when I was not sick or drunk, would be reasonably convincing.



God didnt make salvation easy to find. He speaks of that in the parables of the pearl and the treasure. Not even miracles (especially done in light of modern technology) can open the eyes to salvation... it has to be let in.

You may be convinced by an angel in a burning bush, but the influence of the world is always working in our minds, many may find resons to doubt even after such a miraculous occurance. Unbelievable Miracles can be quite Unbelievable at times.
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Well, someone talking directly to me out of a burning bush, when I was not sick or drunk, would be reasonably convincing.



God didnt make salvation easy to find. He speaks of that in the parables of the pearl and the treasure. Not even miracles (especially done in light of modern technology) can open the eyes to salvation... it has to be let in.

You may be convinced by an angel in a burning bush, but the influence of the world is always working in our minds, many may find resons to doubt even after such a miraculous occurance. Unbelievable Miracles can be quite Unbelievable at times.



I have never needed to resort to a supernatural explanation for anything I've observed in the world, or in the skies.
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have never needed to resort to a supernatural explanation for anything I've observed in the world, or in the skies.



Neither have I in my outward observations, as long as I don't look to close. But look within, the mystery of what makes you, you is quite metaphysical.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Or someone takes loving care of you your entire life and then, when they die, you ask for "proof" that they actually loved you at all.



Not as of yet, but perhaps someday, an autopsy may actually answer that question. Of course, if someone were to request such a procedure on a deceased loved one, it would probably be more interesting to look into their brain's biochemistry.

Life is like going to see a magician. You may find your friend who keeps explaining to you how all the tricks work incredibly annoying, but that doesn't make him wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Well, someone talking directly to me out of a burning bush, when I was not sick or drunk, would be reasonably convincing.



God didnt make salvation easy to find. He speaks of that in the parables of the pearl and the treasure. Not even miracles (especially done in light of modern technology) can open the eyes to salvation... it has to be let in.

You may be convinced by an angel in a burning bush, but the influence of the world is always working in our minds, many may find resons to doubt even after such a miraculous occurance. Unbelievable Miracles can be quite Unbelievable at times.



Ever heard the saying "look hard enough for something, and you'll find it?"

Example:

A person thinks their SO is cheating on them or no longer loves them. Their jealousy, acts, and possible accusations may drive that other person away or into the arms of another whereas if there wasn't the seed to begin with, they might have been together forever.

In the above scenario, I'd personally not succumb to those feelings or let them influence me until I had reason to believe something was going on.

I think of religion sort of the same way. If I were to believe in a higher power I'd probably be able to find things that I'd feel enforced that belief, but the issue is, I'm no longer objective.

"If all you have is hammer, every problem is a nail."

A supreme being is the ultimate hammer.

The interesting thing about this whole discussion is it may have shown me why it is so hard to debate religion.

Athiests argue the existence of supreme being(s) whereas religious people only care about their belief in them. It seems to me, the actually existence of such a being(s) is seemingly inconsequential in their minds. To them, it's their belief that makes them real which in a way sort of does to them.

Sorta like the pro life/pro choice debates, they aren't exactly defined opposites.
Stupidity if left untreated is self-correcting
If ya can't be good, look good, if that fails, make 'em laugh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Not as of yet, but perhaps someday, an autopsy may actually answer that question. Of course, if someone were to request such a procedure on a deceased loved one, it would probably be more interesting to look into their brain's biochemistry.

Life is like going to see a magician. You may find your friend who keeps explaining to you how all the tricks work incredibly annoying, but that doesn't make him wrong.



Im trying to understand your mind in light of these statements, and Im having a little difficulty (which is not your fault at all). The brainchemistry thing is very interesting, but I dont think it really addresses the point about how love gets to one mind from another. I believe it has to be let in, and it seems you think differently. How things work have never been much interest to me, but why things work has, and this could be the difference between yours and my brain chemistry, but I am fighting to understand where your coming from.

For me life is a miracle, so explaining how it works is not as important as understanding why it works. Nothing in life is worth anything without life. Again, you and I think differently but that doesnt mean we are wrong. If the absolute scientific truth, met the absolute spiritual truth, the one that is more important to life would have the greatest universal power, (as it relates to life) but it seems that the design of our minds is so, that some crave one over the other.

Basically for me I have found that life has no worth on this planet without love. That there is something incredibly fascinating about how powerful love actually is... it just ignites us and fills us with life to the fullest. It doesnt take anything away, though we still deal with loss, on the contrary, it gives and gives and gives. While the balance seems to need both the light and the dark, my hope and my desire is to persevere in the light.
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

A person thinks their SO is cheating on them or no longer loves them. Their jealousy, acts, and possible accusations may drive that other person away or into the arms of another whereas if there wasn't the seed to begin with, they might have been together forever.



Paranoia is fear based and love is greater than fear; For me that is not something I had to look too hard for, just seems to make sense to me. I am aware that can be an arbitrary statement to the more argumentative types, but for me, I find the answer in this question, "Does love save us from fear, or does fear save us from love?"

Quote

In the above scenario, I'd personally not succumb to those feelings or let them influence me until I had reason to believe something was going on.



Sounds true to me :)

Quote

I think of religion sort of the same way. If I were to believe in a higher power I'd probably be able to find things that I'd feel enforced that belief, but the issue is, I'm no longer objective.



This is where it gets a little fuzzy in my head... Theres something here, but I have to think on it. Sounds like the revelation vs reason thing we were discussing earlier with champu.

The assumption in your scenario is that the reason comes before the revelation, or that the reason found the revelation, but at least in my case, it was the revelation that found the reasoning. I wasnt looking for reason to support the revelation of God, (It was far more powerful than I can explain), instead, the revelation gives the reasoning quite freely and suprisingly at times, if I remain open and free to think freely.

And, if my mind is open within the revelation then perhaps its not as objective as it appears? If I am considered objective because I am filled with a gratitude (that goes way beyond my worth), through the revelation, then you would be right. Theres a sensative line here somewehre, but it is a line still.

Quote

"If all you have is hammer, every problem is a nail."

A supreme being is the ultimate hammer



The supreme being could also be considered the scientific mind as well. There are plenty who believe science is the truth and the ultimate hammer. And I dont think I am just being argumentative, at least I hope not.


Quote

Athiests argue the existence of supreme being(s) whereas religious people only care about their belief in them. It seems to me, the actually existence of such a being(s) is seemingly inconsequential in their minds. To them, it's their belief that makes them real which in a way sort of does to them.



I can see the reach for reason and understanding here, and it is appreciated, but its racked with inconsistency, assumption, and bias in my mind (I say that with all respect). Ultimately, the revelation of God is being grossly underestimated. I did not reveal anything, God reveals himself, and the experience is quite humbling to say the least, in a very grace-filled way. My experieince did not happen in a church with many poeple ect... I was completely alone in a room in my apartment, the rest im afraid you wouldnt believe.

Back to the objectivity thing. I think the problem isnt God, its what people believe in regards to him. But, we should discuss that a little further. For now, ill just post this.
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The interesting thing about this whole discussion is it may have shown me why it is so hard to debate religion.

Athiests argue the existence of supreme being(s) whereas religious people only care about their belief in them. It seems to me, the actually existence of such a being(s) is seemingly inconsequential in their minds. To them, it's their belief that makes them real which in a way sort of does to them.




My understanding of God is that He created us with a need to search for Truth and has given us the ability to find it. Whether we are unraveling His physical creation through scientific study or trying to work out the mysteries of His love. Man made religions, as you say, creates a belief system and then reshapes god into the image of their dogma. Spiritual communion with God is a very personal experience, you either grasp the depth of your need and allow God to fill it or you reject Him and attempt to fill it yourself.

...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

God didnt make salvation easy to find. He speaks of that in the parables of the pearl and the treasure.



I know i took one sentence out of your paragraph, but i felt the need to address it. Salvation is not hard to find at all. "Seek ye first the kingdom of god and all of the other things shall be added unto you"

Salvation is a prayer away. If you invite Jesus Christ into you life, it shall be done, it's God's promise to us. Simple as that.

God is a jealous God. Be ye not decieved: "God is NOT mocked."
-Richard-
"You're Holding The Rope And I'm Taking The Fall"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

God didnt make salvation easy to find. He speaks of that in the parables of the pearl and the treasure.



I know i took one sentence out of your paragraph, but i felt the need to address it. Salvation is not hard to find at all. "Seek ye first the kingdom of god and all of the other things shall be added unto you"

Salvation is a prayer away. If you invite Jesus Christ into you life, it shall be done, it's God's promise to us. Simple as that.

God is a jealous God. Be ye not decieved: "God is NOT mocked."



God is mocked daily. God (assuming His existence) does not appear to care anymore than I would care if I were to be mocked by ants. One has to think that an omniscient and omnipotent being would find humans to be quite insignificant.
As for salvation, I believe the rules on that are a bit more stringent than one prayer. For example, I seem to recall Jesus inviting a man to give up all his wealth to come follow him, because rich folk will have a difficult time getting into heaven.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

If one truly wanted to help save mankind from their evil ways, why would anyone not want direct proof if it encouraged more to follow in his path? How could that be a bad thing?



The religious faithful absolutely do not want this to happen; and isn't it an irony that it is the skeptics that would most welcome it - because we are open to evidence and will follow it to whatever truth to which it leads.

It would be game over for those that live by faith-based principles if we are ever presented with the answers to the big questions.

Kind of like the philosophers in the Hitchhikers Guide who realize that if the ultimate questions get answered via actual observation and objective analysis of information; they'll be out of a job.
" . . . the lust for power can be just as completely satisfied by suggesting people into loving their servitude as by flogging them and kicking them into obedience." -- Aldous Huxley

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

From http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=3754539#3754539

Quote

The physical manifestation of God is not necessary and would actually be a detriment.



Discuss. :)


Exactly. They not only like oogie-boogie, they absolutely need it to stay in place.
" . . . the lust for power can be just as completely satisfied by suggesting people into loving their servitude as by flogging them and kicking them into obedience." -- Aldous Huxley

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I know i took one sentence out of your paragraph, but i felt the need to address it. Salvation is not
Quote

hard to find at all. "Seek ye first the kingdom of god and all of the other things shall be added unto you"

Salvation is a prayer away. If you invite Jesus Christ into you life, it shall be done, it's God's promise to us. Simple as that.

God is a jealous God. Be ye not decieved: "God is NOT mocked."



For some, the search takes a lifetime. But your right, when it is found, it is found, and that is the promise. Not sure why you told me not to mock God though, unless you think I was?
"We didn't start the fire"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0