Recommended Posts
skipbelt 0
Quotevoyager !
Nope, sorry.
Originally employed as a weapon of war, the hammer nowadays is used as a
kind of divining rod to locate the most expensive parts adjacent the
object we are trying to hit.
quade 4
Quotevoyager !
I'm not certain you understand the concept.
In order for something to be a perpetual motion machine it would have to create more energy than put into it. It has to be able to use that excess energy not only to overcome its own friction, but also be able to do some sort of "work." Not simply move for a very long time.
Even something like a fusion generator wouldn't be considered a perpetual motion machine because it uses a consumable fuel.
The World's Most Boring Skydiver
skipbelt 0
billvon 2,991
>machine in perpetual motion !
Well, by that definition, so is a cruise ship.
quade 4
Quote>voyager wouldn't fit that concept , but most certainly is a man made
>machine in perpetual motion !
Well, by that definition, so is a cruise ship.
Or the turbines at Hoover Damn.
Still not a perpetual motion machine.
The World's Most Boring Skydiver
muff528 3
QuoteQuoteQuote>Can't extract energy from the existence of gravity because theres no way
>to set up a gradient.
Sure there is; just go up. Gravity falls off (slowly) over miles. A large enough device could see a significant gradient.
But that doesn't matter. A gradient of any force (gravity, magnetism, charge attraction) won't give you energy, even with clever devices.
Yeah, taking it to an extreme, a black hole's gravitational field can have a very large "gradient" across atomic distances.
So?
Maybe some energy could be extracted from the so-called "Hawking radiation". A virtual particle/antiparticle pair appears, because of a vacuum quantum fluctuation, near the event horizon and one of them is sucked into the black hole and the other is emitted as radiation before they can zap each other. I suppose that is one way to "extract energy from the existence of gravity..." because of a gravitational gradient. Probably wouldn't be very useful for weight reduction, space drives or skydiving in the near future though.
I think we're all Bozos on this bus.
Falcon5232, SCS8170, SCSA353, POPS9398, DS239
champu 1
QuoteOh, well now I'm not sure I'd agree with that Champu, after all, fantastic musings about this neat new force we don't understand yet in the 1800's eventually led to highly evolved and useful toys based on manipulating that force, like the computer you typed that message on.
Electricity ring a bell?
"What!? By using this com-PUE-ter I'm using 'lectricity!? Not on my watch!*"
But in all seriousness... there's a difference between musings and fantastic musings. A better understanding of the underlying nature of gravity may indeed allow us to create some cool technologies that we don't currently have, but that's no reason to revive all the snake oil claims from the 1800's about electromagnetism that didn't come true.
* "...which, by the way, is mech-a-canical!"
skipbelt 0
QuoteQuote>voyager wouldn't fit that concept , but most certainly is a man made
>machine in perpetual motion !
Well, by that definition, so is a cruise ship.
Or the turbines at Hoover Damn.
Still not a perpetual motion machine.
these are being propelled voyager is not , it will remain in motion with no further motive force perpetually !
billvon 2,991
If you cut the engines on a cruise ship, it will coast along for half an hour or so. If you cut the engines on Voyager, it will coast along for centuries or so. But eventually both will come to a stop, due to either drag or running into something.
rehmwa 2
QuoteIf the 2nd Law of thermodynamics could be repealed it would be possible to build a perpetual motion machine.
COOL - Let's write Congress and have them get right on it, then the pres can sign off - it's the ultimate "Green" project and all we need is another law passed to make it happen.
...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants
kallend 2,027
QuoteQuoteIf the 2nd Law of thermodynamics could be repealed it would be possible to build a perpetual motion machine.
COOL - Let's write Congress and have them get right on it, then the pres can sign off - it's the ultimate "Green" project and all we need is another law passed to make it happen.
That would be about as effective as defining pi = 3 ((I Kings 7:23).
The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.
rehmwa 2
QuoteQuoteQuoteIf the 2nd Law of thermodynamics could be repealed it would be possible to build a perpetual motion machine.
COOL - Let's write Congress and have them get right on it, then the pres can sign off - it's the ultimate "Green" project and all we need is another law passed to make it happen.
That would be about as effective as defining pi = 3 ((I Kings 7:23).
nonsense - that was for the ignorant hicks - like republicans
this would be for the ENVIRONMENT!!! smart people like liberals should be all over that kind of legislation
...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants
champu 1
Quote...voyager... ...voyager... ...voyager...
No love for Pioneer 10 and 11...
skipbelt 0
billvon 2,991
Incorrect! Outer space is filled with gas (mainly hydrogen) and dust. Even in the cleanest part of space you see densities of 1-2 particles per cubic meter. That generates an infinitesimal amount of drag, but it is present, and will eventually stop Voyager. (Although as I mentioned it's more likely to hit something first.)
skipbelt 0
Amazon 7
Quote>outer space is a vacuum , therefore no drag . . .
Incorrect! Outer space is filled with gas (mainly hydrogen) and dust. Even in the cleanest part of space you see densities of 1-2 particles per cubic meter. That generates an infinitesimal amount of drag, but it is present, and will eventually stop Voyager. (Although as I mentioned it's more likely to hit something first.)
But on the other hand... the density of many posters in SC is severly affecting the entire solar system.
QuoteQuoteQuote>voyager wouldn't fit that concept , but most certainly is a man made
>machine in perpetual motion !
Well, by that definition, so is a cruise ship.
Or the turbines at Hoover Damn.
Still not a perpetual motion machine.
these are being propelled voyager is not , it will remain in motion with no further motive force perpetually !
Voyager is constantly under the influence of "motive force". It is called gravity. Voyagers path is constantly being altered by the ever changing influence of the gravitational forces of countless bodies. Voyager may be perpetually moving, but it's motion is determined almost entirely by outside forces. This is just the opposite of what a perpetual motion machine is required to do, which is to operate for an infinite amount of time without energy being added once the motion has started.
Originally employed as a weapon of war, the hammer nowadays is used as a
kind of divining rod to locate the most expensive parts adjacent the
object we are trying to hit.
Amazon 7
QuoteQuoteQuoteQuote>voyager wouldn't fit that concept , but most certainly is a man made
>machine in perpetual motion !
Well, by that definition, so is a cruise ship.
Or the turbines at Hoover Damn.
Still not a perpetual motion machine.
these are being propelled voyager is not , it will remain in motion with no further motive force perpetually !
Voyager is constantly under the influence of "motive force". It is called gravity. Voyagers path is constantly being altered by the ever changing influence of the gravitational forces of countless bodies. Voyager may be perpetually moving, but it's motion is determined almost entirely by outside forces. This is just the opposite of what a perpetual motion machine is required to do, which is to operate for an infinite amount of time without energy being added once the motion has started.
http://heavens-above.com/solar-escape.asp?lat=0&lng=0&loc=Unspecified&alt=0&tz=CET
turtlespeed 220
QuoteQuote>outer space is a vacuum , therefore no drag . . .
Incorrect! Outer space is filled with gas (mainly hydrogen) and dust. Even in the cleanest part of space you see densities of 1-2 particles per cubic meter. That generates an infinitesimal amount of drag, but it is present, and will eventually stop Voyager. (Although as I mentioned it's more likely to hit something first.)
But on the other hand... the density of many posters in SC is severly affecting the entire solar system.
Only the liberals that portray themselves as liberitarians.
BTR #1 / OTB^5 Official #2 / Hellfish #408 / VSCR #108/Tortuga/Orfun
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites