0
billvon

Oxygen usage (was: incident at Perris)

Recommended Posts

>I base my opinion on having been the Phys. Tec. on over 25 jumps
>form 24,000 msl or higher and having made 40 or more from that
> altitude. If you put the butt end of the hose in your mouth and hold
>it tight you will breath through your nose.

That's exactly right. Your mouth and your nose connect, though. When you breathe in, air from your nose mixes with pure oxygen from your mouth, and you end up with all that oxygen in your lungs. When you breathe out, the air from your lungs and the extra oxygen from your mouth goes out your nose. Should be no difference from a cannula that's used correctly, and should be much better than the way most people use cannulas (simply pointed more or less at your nose.)

At the 300 ways we made 5000+ jumps at altitudes from 22,000 to 24,000 MSL. Originally we tried to use the cannula systems in the helmets; they didn't work well, and by the end of the attempt most of the people I saw were sticking the tubes in their mouths. We did have some hypoxia problems, but they were mostly caused by aircraft going off oxygen too soon. Using the tube in the mouth has some advantages for big-ways, the main one being that you can go off O2 later by just pulling the tube off and going. Being on oxygen an extra 10 seconds can make a big difference when you're exiting from 24,000 MSL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yes, your mouth and nose connect, but you can not bring in air or O2 through you mouth while you are holding a tube. 1 to 1.5 L flow is not enough to overcome the pressure of air coming in through you nose. If you made that many jumps from above 18000 msl with out pre-breathing you are just lucky. Even then, some people may have joint problems in the future. Thats not my opinion it just the facts of humans going to higher altitudes.
Sparky
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>Yes, your mouth and nose connect, but you can not bring in air or
>O2 through you mouth while you are holding a tube.

?? You can't keep it OUT. If you try to close your throat your cheeks swell up like a chipmunk and you end up spitting out the hose. There's a decent amount of pressure in the plenum.

>1 to 1.5 L flow is not enough to overcome the pressure of air coming in through you nose.

1L is a measure of volume, not pressure. Also, the pressure in your lungs drops when you breathe in; that's how your lungs work to bring in air. The pressure in your nose doesn't rise. There are no pumping mechanisms in your nose.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have what I think is a great system when I have to jump with oxygen. I have my own nasal canular that has a plastic cone on the end. I place that end in the oxygen tube coming from the aircraft. I jump with a Factory Diver, and put the nasal canular under my nose, tighten the end around the back of my head, and put my helmet on. When the call comes to get off the oxygen, I simply reach behind me and pull the tubes apart and stick the end in my jumpsuit. Since I have the Factory Diver on the nasal canular stays put.
May your trails be crooked, winding, lonesome, dangerous, leading to the most amazing view. May your mountains rise into and above the clouds. - Edward Abbey

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bill,
You seem to have all the right answers so I am going to let it go. But you might want to give some thought to why the military has the procedures they are using. Do you think it just to fill the pages in a lesson plan?
Be Safe!
Sparky
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

But you might want to give some thought to why the military has the procedures they are using. Do you think it just to fill the pages in a lesson plan?



As a Military HALO Jumpmaster I have to agree with him on this fact. As I've stated before in threads about high altitude jumps, skydivers have been getting away with questionable shit for years, that doesn't make it right or the correct way to do it. There is a reason based on medical fact, not SWAG, why we prebreath for at least 30 mins on the ground and why ones mask seal must remain constant. Sucking on a hose may get you to altitude but if something went wrong with a jumper or the pilot who would be able to handle the situation appropriately? Not someone who has been holding a platic tube between their lips from 10k up.
"It's just skydiving..additional drama is not required"
Some people dream about flying, I live my dream
SKYMONKEY PUBLISHING

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>skydivers have been getting away with questionable shit for years,
> that doesn't make it right or the correct way to do it. There is a
> reason based on medical fact . . .

That's why I'm asking. I have no doubt that the military has procedures that work. However, the military is a very different environment than the sport parachuting world, and things that work in the civilian world (tiny elliptical canopies for example) may have no place in a military environment. That doesn't mean that small ellipticals cannot be jumped, just that they are better suited for the civilian world than the military world. Similarly, a different procedure for skydiver oxygen usage may be entirely appropriate for the different sort of jumping that civilians do.

So have there been any tests that show people _cannot_ perform if they don't prebreathe oxygen, or if they go on oxygen above 8000 feet, or if the same flow comes orally rather than nasally?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Without pre-breathing you are going to altitude with nitrogen in you system. As pressure decreases this nitrogen can be released in to your blood stream in the form of bubbles. This can do anything from make your joints sore to kill you. It can come on fast or it can come on slow. Going above 18,000 without pre-breathing and a sealed mask is not only dangerous, it is foolish.
Sparky
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So have there been any tests that show people _cannot_ perform if they don't prebreathe oxygen, or if they go on oxygen above 8000 feet, or if the same flow comes orally rather than nasally?



It is common knowledge the effects of hypoxia can induce symtoms at altitudes as low as 8000 feet. Its well documented in even primary pilots training especially in regards to flying at night.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't have any reports off hand that I can point you to for reference(I'm sure many could be googled) but having sat in the chamber many times and had phys techs as well as flight surgeons explain the medicne behind it to me each time, there is one thing I am sure of and have witnessed in a real environment. If the seal on your mask is compromised and you breath any ambient air you are not doing yourself any good as you are now introducing nitrogen back into your system and your potential for getting the bends and or other high altitude sicknesses increases exponetially.It's not based on military application or civillian, it's just the way physiology works( not that I am claiming to be a SME on it). Perhaps our Phys Tech friend will expound on anything I failed to mention or cover thoughly.

The whole purpose of having a mask that covers your mouth and nose is to avoid breathing in any ambient air while hooked up to O2. If your breathing ambient and O2 you aren't really doing yourself any good other than replacing your already rapidly depleted O2 in your system. It's much like leaving the engine running while filling the gas tank except the engine is burning gas as fast if not faster then the gas is being added. The added danger is that the guy pumping the gas is holding a blow torch called nitrogen in his other hand.

IMO, the best way to approach this for civillian skydiving that is agreeable from both a cost as well as a safety standpoint is to use only full face(nose and mouth) masks on aviation quality O2 with skydivers starting breathing at 8000 feet with a ceiling(exit altitude) no higher than 17999 and duration of time at altitude no longer than necessary. In an ideal situation, A/C permitting, the base would have a smaller console or bottle positioned near the door for the sole purpose of allowing them to stay on O2 for as long as possible while positioning or even have their own bail out bottles inside their jumpsuit that they could switch to during climb out.

I know this brings other issues like helmets into play and divers and so on and there are several different ways to skin that cat but I won't dillute this topic with them.
"It's just skydiving..additional drama is not required"
Some people dream about flying, I live my dream
SKYMONKEY PUBLISHING

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I don't have any reports off hand that I can point you to for reference(I'm sure many could be googled) but having sat in the chamber many times and had phys techs as well as flight surgeons explain the medicne behind it to me each time, there is one thing I am sure of and have witnessed in a real environment. If the seal on your mask is compromised and you breath any ambient air you are not doing yourself any good as you are now introducing nitrogen back into your system and your potential for getting the bends and or other high altitude sicknesses increases exponetially.It's not based on military application or civillian, it's just the way physiology works( not that I am claiming to be a SME on it). Perhaps our Phys Tech friend will expound on anything I failed to mention or cover thoughly.

The whole purpose of having a mask that covers your mouth and nose is to avoid breathing in any ambient air while hooked up to O2. If your breathing ambient and O2 you aren't really doing yourself any good other than replacing your already rapidly depleted O2 in your system. It's much like leaving the engine running while filling the gas tank except the engine is burning gas as fast if not faster then the gas is being added. The added danger is that the guy pumping the gas is holding a blow torch called nitrogen in his other hand.

IMO, the best way to approach this for civillian skydiving that is agreeable from both a cost as well as a safety standpoint is to use only full face(nose and mouth) masks on aviation quality O2 with skydivers starting breathing at 8000 feet with a ceiling(exit altitude) no higher than 17999 and duration of time at altitude no longer than necessary. In an ideal situation, A/C permitting, the base would have a smaller console or bottle positioned near the door for the sole purpose of allowing them to stay on O2 for as long as possible while positioning or even have their own bail out bottles inside their jumpsuit that they could switch to during climb out.

I know this brings other issues like helmets into play and divers and so on and there are several different ways to skin that cat but I won't dillute this topic with them.



What is the difference between aviator's oxygen, medical oxygen, and welders oxygen?

Doesn't the FAA allow cannulas to 25k?
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Here is a good read to answer your questions and many more about this topic.

O2 Information



Thanks - seems like all O2 is the same except in the eyes of your insurer, cannulas are good to 18k, and the bends is only a problem with fast climbing aircraft going above 20k in less than 20 minutes (Mullins' King Air?)
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Aviation O2 has a lower moisture content. Important so water doesn't collect and freeze in the system. This is also why you end up with dry mouth, nose and throat from it.

Medical O2 has a higher moisture content. My guess is so that it's more tolerable for long term usage as it helps avoid the dry mouth, nose and throat.

Industrial (welder's) O2 can have a higher level of impurities that may be harmful to humans.

More info HERE.
quade -
The World's Most Boring Skydiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>It is common knowledge the effects of hypoxia can induce symtoms
>at altitudes as low as 8000 feet. Its well documented in even primary
> pilots training especially in regards to flying at night.

Interesting, in that pilots are not required to use it below 12,500 and many aircraft cabins are only pressurized to 10,000 feet - and the pilots breathe cabin air in those aircraft.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Actually, it can affect night vision typically as low as 5,000 msl. The way this is typically demonstrated is for the student to attempt to read a chart in low light levels off O2 at this altitude and then give him a few puffs of O2. It's like turning on a light switch.

As for the requirement for pilots above 12,500 -- inducing symptoms and affecting safety of flight are two different numbers. There's also the amount of exposure and amount of activity to be considered as well.

Further, I've always been amazed by the guys that climb mountains without O2. It's one thing to be off it for a few seconds in the door waiting for exit and another thing entirely climbing up the side of a mountain at 18,000 msl.
quade -
The World's Most Boring Skydiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

So the primary concern above 18,000 feet (assuming the jumper is on the FAA-recommended O2 flows) is decompression sickness? Interesting.



No, I don't think that's quite right.

Certainly at some point and with some rapidity of accent that's an issue and above about 60,000 feet all sorts of nasty things happen without a pressure suit, but I would have to say that the main issue at levels between say 8,000 to 30,000 are lack of O2 to the brain.

After all, if you began to get nitrogen bends at 24,000 all you'd really have to do to get rid of them would be to descend. However, if you lost consciousness, well, that's another story entirely -- you wouldn't be able to take corrective action because, well, you'd be unconscious.
quade -
The World's Most Boring Skydiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

. If the seal on your mask is compromised and you breath any ambient air you are not doing yourself any good as you are now introducing nitrogen back into your system and your potential for getting the bends and or other high altitude sicknesses increases exponetially.It's not based on military application or civillian, it's just the way physiology works( not that I am claiming to be a SME on it). Perhaps our Phys Tech friend will expound on anything I failed to mention or cover thoughly.



Interesting. I did the chamber when I was in Brazil a few years ago. Being of smaller build, and the fact that it was a military chamber, we had trouble finding masks which fit me. It took a long time to fit me at the beginning, and after I had removed the mask and put it back on in the chamber - it wasn't quite sealed right. I stayed somewhat dizzy unless I held it on tightly to my face - by holding it on I was ok, but I still felt pretty weird for a good portion of the day. I wonder if my reaction had to do with not having a good seal on the mask?

Interestingly enough - the Brazilian military was going to make us wear oxygen to go to 15k. And not only that - but we would have to pre-breathe oxygen for some amount of time, and the oxygen setup we had to wear was pretty much a full pilot-style hard helmet - with a mask that covered your whole nose and mouth (well in my case my entire face!) We weren't particularly upset when the C130 blew an engine and we had to do only 13k jumps out of a different plane.

W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Further, I've always been amazed by the guys that climb mountains without O2. It's one thing to be off it for a few seconds in the door waiting for exit and another thing entirely climbing up the side of a mountain at 18,000 msl.



In Mt. climbing it is generally recommended that one not ascend more than a 1000 ft. in a day when at altitude, which is why many camps are set up and several trips are made up only to come back down and then continue higher. This allows the body to better adapt to the stress of less O2 during excertion over a period of time. As a side note this theroy is also being used by atheletes in sealed rooms that allows them to "sleep high" and train low for better O2 absorbtion and usage at lower levels(read normal)

Another bag of worm I didn't want to open and it was mentioned in the article I referenced is types of systems(consoles), Constant flow and on demand and the regulation of the flow to individual jumpers. All I've seen on civillian O2 jumps is one big bottle usually under the seat or by the pilot and all the medical sized lines running off of it. I'm pretty sure the guy furthest from the bottle isn't getting the same flow as the guy next to it unless there is a prett good regulation system on it. When you get to the really high altitudes the O2 can come out of the mask like compressed air and can be a challenge to breath if you open your mouth and breath in as it literally fills your lungs up instantly. The thing to remember is the EPT given are for pilots sitting in an A/C, not skydivers moving around and getting amped about the dive. Throw in smoking, hangovers, sickness , or general poor health and it gets even lower on the EPT scale very quickly.
"It's just skydiving..additional drama is not required"
Some people dream about flying, I live my dream
SKYMONKEY PUBLISHING

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lou,
To my knowledge there are no "civilian consoles". The ones we use at AERO are six man conex systems and our masks have demand reg. on them. If you go above 43000 msl you need pressure breathing equipment to force O2 in and above 62-63000 msl you need a pressure suit, ie space suit or your blood will boil. At 25000 your time of useful consciousness is measured in just min. and at 30000 it is measured in sec. Above 18000 and surely above 24000 is not a game it serious and dangerous. Once you are at altitude you can have a leak in your mask because the nitrogen you breath will not expand unless you go higher.
Sparky
Sparky
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

To my knowledge there are no "civilian consoles". The ones we use at AERO are six man conex systems and our masks have demand reg. on them



The AirForce and the Army are slowly changing over from the MBU-12 to the PHAOS system, although it has limited usage approval right now, some units are curently using it. But the MBU-12 system is still widely encountered. I'm assuming the console you are familiar with is the one manufactured by para flight, as are all military HALO parachutes and other equipment.

I think the consoles and masks are available to the public from para flite or something very close to it as it is used for commercial aviation in some situations.

[/url]http://www.paraflite.com/html/oxygen1.html

http://www.paraflite.com/html/oxygen2.html[url]


Just found my FM31-19 Military free fall parachuting manual.

Oxygen forms:

Gaseous oxygen: Gaseous aviator's breathing oxygen is designated Grade A, Type I, Military Spec MIL-0-27210E. No other manufactured O2 is acceptable. The difference between aviator's and medical or technical (welders) O2 is the absence of water vapor. The purity reqs for for aviators O2 is 99.5% by volume. I tmay not contain more than 0.0005 milligram of water vapor per liter at 760 millimeters of mercury and 68 degrees F. I t must be odorless and free from contaminates, including drying agents.

gaseous-Low pressure :Low pressure aviators breathing O2 is stored in yellow, light weight shatterproof cylinders. They are filled to a max pressure of 450psi and are considered empty when at 100psi.

Gaseous-high pressure: High pressure aviators breathing O2 is stored in lime green , heavy weight ,shatterproof bottles stenciled with AVIATORS BREATHING OXYGEN. They can be filled to a max pressure of 2200psi.

LIQUID OXYGEN: Liquid aviators O2 is designated Grade B , type II, MIL SPEC MIL-0-27210E. LOX's most common usage is in storage facilities and for aircraft oxygen supplies because a large quantity can be carried in a small space.

* All personnel will prebreath 100 % O2 at or below 10,000 feet MSL pressure or cabin altitude below 10,000 feet MSL pressure on any mission scheduled to drop at or above 18,000 feet MSL

* The required prebreathing time will be completed before the 20 min warning and before the cabin altitude ascends through 10,000 feet MSL.

* A break in prebreathing requires restarting the prebreathing period or removing the individual from the jump.

* prebreathing requires the presence of an AF phys tech onboard the A/C

* all personnel onboard during unpressurized operations above 10,000 feet MSL and higher will use O2(exception: parachutists may operate without supplental O2 during unpressurized flights up to 13,000 feet MSL provided the time above 10,000 feet MSL does not exceed 30 mins each sortie)

There is a catchy table describing the requirements but I'll post the one most like ly to be used by civillian jumpers.

Deplyment altitude: At or above 13,000 feet MSL but Below 18,000 feet MSL: ONboard O2: Supplemental O2 at normal before ascending through 10,000 feet MSL or cabin altitude; HALO ops: Supplemental O2 at normal from 1 min warning until canopy deployment below 10,000 feet MSL

notes: 1: Supplemental O2 means each jumper will have his own O2 mask and regulator
2: All prebreathing will be conducted at or below 10,000 feet MSL or 10,000 feet MSL cabin pressure.


At or above 18,000 feet MSL up to 25,000 feet MSL requires 100% O2 for 30 mins and from 1 min warning until canopy deplyment below 10,000 feet MSL
"It's just skydiving..additional drama is not required"
Some people dream about flying, I live my dream
SKYMONKEY PUBLISHING

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

>It is common knowledge the effects of hypoxia can induce symtoms
>at altitudes as low as 8000 feet. Its well documented in even primary
> pilots training especially in regards to flying at night.

Interesting, in that pilots are not required to use it below 12,500 and many aircraft cabins are only pressurized to 10,000 feet - and the pilots breathe cabin air in those aircraft.



Bill this in regards to flying at night and these symtoms are milder than the blue finger tingling and sluggish lacking motor skills. We are talking about night peripheral vision and color recognition.
These are some of the benign symtoms which may have an effect at night. Sometimes these effects are made worse by caffiene. People are very different it is hard to predict how someone will react to partial gas pressures. So a safety margin for many may very well exclude a few individuals who process O2 differently.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
since you definitely seem to be the man to ask,

what do the physical O2 requirements mean for high altitude wingsuit flight? is it feasible with bottles and does the wingsuit 'work' well enough to be worth the effort & risks at higher altitudes?

i've wondered about high altitude wingsuits the instant i got down from my flight
____________________________________
Those who fail to learn from the past are simply Doomed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0