Recommended Posts
QuoteQuoteor popping toggles and immediately doing a braked turn
No. Popping the toggles requires the jumper to get a grip on both toggles (and despite your BASE jumping desires, most skydivers do not use big grab toggles), and then it requires both brakes to release cleanly or you have just made two problems out of one. You started off with an imminent canopy collision, and have now added a canopy with a comprimised control system.
The rear riser turn can be accomplished with a grip anywhere on the rear riser, and will result in a more effective amount of response vs. the amount of input required. Pulling a toggle only effects the tail of the canopy, while pulling a rear riser will effect the entire back half of the canopy.
Another advantage is being able to grab the rears while keeping your eyes on the traffic hazzard. If you have to look up to grab your toggles, you're not watching the guy you're in a rush to avoid. It's much easier to grab the rears sight unseen, while continuing to watch the other guy.
Back to your BASE intentions, check with your mentors, and they'll tell you that rear risers can be used to turn, brake turn, stall turn, or back up your canopy if you open facing an object. Again, quicker and more reliable than going for toggles.
All this is true, but you can still fly your canopy using harness imput long before you can reach risers. This is not a "one or the other" answer.
Many tools a box should carry?
"Son, only two things fall from the sky."
QuoteAll this is true, but you can still fly your canopy using harness imput long before you can reach risers. This is not a "one or the other" answer.
Many tools a box should carry?
In this case, the discussion is about taking evasive action in the event of a possible collision on opening. Even my Velo at 2.0 does not provide the same 'instant' turn you can get from rears or toggles. Anyone with less canopy or at a lower WL will have even less response, and I think it's a mistake to put a harness turn forward as a tool for collision avoidance.
Case in point, I would split hairs down to the differences between the time it takes to grip and release a toggle vs, the time it takes to grip and pull a rear riser, and call the rear riser the clear choice in a collision.
I would further split hairs calling the time it takes to make a full toggle stroke vs the time it takes to make a full rear riser input, and call the rear riser again the superior choice.
Time is of the essence in these situations, and given the amount of 'suck' that comes with a wrap, I would say that the 1 or 1.5 seconds of time you save using the rears vs the toggles makes the rears the outstanding winning choice. Compare that to the turn rate/responsiveness of the harness turn, and you can see how I would not even mention that option in this circumstance.
DocPop 1
Quote
All this is true, but you can still fly your canopy using harness imput long before you can reach risers. This is not a "one or the other" answer.
Many tools a box should carry?
You may be able to initiate a harness turn faster while you are reaching for a rear riser, but the rate of that turn is going to be significantly slower on all but highly loaded ellipticals and x-braces and may not be enough to get you out of trouble.
In other words the total time take to reach up, grab a rear and turn 45 degrees would be significantly less than the time taken to initiate a harness turn and allow it to turn 45 degrees. This time differential gets larger as the WL of the canopy gets lower.
~ CanuckInUSA
billvon 2,990
>thru the opening sequence.
Agreed - but a caveat there is that with many canopies, trying to fly them through deployment greatly increases your odds of a spinner or other problem opening. Canopies are designed to open symmetrically, with an even load placed on both sets of lines. Rapidly varying the positions/tensions on the lines can contribute to problem openings - spinners, slammers and off-headers.
Quote>This can also be a great tool during deployment. You can esentially fly your canopy
>thru the opening sequence.
Agreed - but a caveat there is that with many canopies, trying to fly them through deployment greatly increases your odds of a spinner or other problem opening. Canopies are designed to open symmetrically, with an even load placed on both sets of lines. Rapidly varying the positions/tensions on the lines can contribute to problem openings - spinners, slammers and off-headers.
Agreed!! Which is why I stated above...
try it high on a seperate pass. Remember, good body position is the best thing you can do to help your canopy open.
I'm not advocating using harness input as a manuver to avoid a canopy collision. I am, however, saying you can use harness inputs to help your canopy open "on heading" whereby you may avoid the situation in the first place.
"Son, only two things fall from the sky."
No. Popping the toggles requires the jumper to get a grip on both toggles (and despite your BASE jumping desires, most skydivers do not use big grab toggles), and then it requires both brakes to release cleanly or you have just made two problems out of one. You started off with an imminent canopy collision, and have now added a canopy with a comprimised control system.
The rear riser turn can be accomplished with a grip anywhere on the rear riser, and will result in a more effective amount of response vs. the amount of input required. Pulling a toggle only effects the tail of the canopy, while pulling a rear riser will effect the entire back half of the canopy.
Another advantage is being able to grab the rears while keeping your eyes on the traffic hazzard. If you have to look up to grab your toggles, you're not watching the guy you're in a rush to avoid. It's much easier to grab the rears sight unseen, while continuing to watch the other guy.
Back to your BASE intentions, check with your mentors, and they'll tell you that rear risers can be used to turn, brake turn, stall turn, or back up your canopy if you open facing an object. Again, quicker and more reliable than going for toggles.
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites