What if the writers of LOST are fans of Dante's Inferno. In this book Dante goes to hell and sees all kinds of different levels. Depending on what kind of sin you committed, you would be in a certain circle of hell. Everyone in hell is dead, except one person, Dante. So the theory goes, everyone on the LOST island is dead and suffering in some way or another. There is only one person that is alive. Can you guess who that would be? Desmond. This would explain why Naomi said the bodies of flight 815 were all found dead. Just some thoughts. I'm probably wrong but oh well.