I've only jumped a couple of times now, but Maytown is what got me hooked on the sport. The best people, best instructors, low key/low pressure environment, very affordable rates, and plenty of encouragement and advice from the seasoned vets. It's a rural airfield, so the niceties of the city may not be as prevalent (bathrooms, sinks, etc.), but it's completely made up by the atmosphere.
They have two 1950s/60s model straight-tail Cessna 182s that have been up-engined, and one that has had wing extensions to squeeze a few more operational feet out of it. While the paint may not be very pretty, these old workhorses seem reliable and are by all accounts lovingly maintained.
The fact that they aren't there to make a buck, but rather just for the love of the sport and to introduce others to this pastime (lifestyle?) only serves to make it a better experience. Even if you're here to just do a tandem jump, it will not be one of the "cattle through the chute" experiences you'll get with some of the bigger for-profit DZs in the region. You'll get personal attention and encouragement from the instructor who will answer any questions you have and will make you feel right at home.
